Open Sesame Lock & Key
Guide

Should You Rekey or Replace After Moving Into a New Home?

You don't know who has a key to your new house. Here's the fastest way to fix that.

April 22, 2026 4 min readBy Tim, Open Sesame Lock & Key

Between previous owners, contractors, cleaners, agents, and family, an average resale home has had more keys made than anyone can account for. Week one is the time to close that loop.

Make a list of every entry

  • Front, back, side, garage service door, basement, shed, and any gate with a padlock.
  • Note which locks match and which don't — that determines whether one key can rule them all.
  • Include the garage keypad code and any smart lock codes left by the previous owner.

Rekey is usually the answer

  • If the hardware is sound, rekeying every exterior cylinder to a single new key is faster and cheaper than a full replacement, and it kills every old key instantly.
  • Replace only the pieces that are failing: a loose knob, a rusted deadbolt, a door that never latched right.

The rest of the first-week list

  • Reset the garage opener code and delete stored remotes.
  • Wipe smart lock user codes and set your own.
  • Check that every exterior door actually latches and locks — a surprising number don't when you test them properly.
Quick answers

Questions about this topic

Don't see your question? Call Tim directly — he answers the phone himself.

(864) 981-3090

Get a quote

Want this handled instead of DIY'd?

Call (864) 981-3090 and describe what's going on — you'll get a fair price range on the same call.

Reach Tim directly

One owner. One phone. No call center.

Calls and texts go straight to Tim — the same person who shows up at your door.

Call now — fastest

(864) 981-3090

Based in

Ware Shoals, SC

Hours

Mon–Sat · 24 hours a day · ET

Contact Us

Tell us what you need — takes about a minute.

Step 01 / 02

We respond within 1 business hour

Mon–Sat · 24 hours a day · ET